How We Keep Your Flooring Shipping Costs Low (We Priced 2,600+ Quotes to Check)

Illustration created with AI for this article. Not a photo of an actual FlooringInc delivery.
Published November 17, 2026, by Kurt Leitinger. Prices captured November 9-11, 2026, and they change, ours included.
You find the right rubber floor for your garage gym, and the price per square foot looks great. Then you type in your ZIP code, the shipping line appears, and that great price isn't so great anymore.
I've been selling rubber flooring for more than 23 years, and freight is still the part of the order I think about most. Our goal is the lowest shipping costs among our primary competitors, so I wanted to know where we really stand. From November 9 to 11, 2026, we pulled 2,621 shipping quotes (1,330 of them from the other three stores) at four online flooring stores, for ZIP codes in 14 cities, using each store's own cart.
Here's what we found. In our November 9-11, 2026 test, FlooringInc had the lowest delivered price (product plus shipping) in all 14 cities on a single 1/4" 4x10 rubber roll, on 500 and 1,000 sq ft of 3/8" rubber rolls and on padded gym turf, against Living.Fit, Elite Floor Supply and Greatmats. On November 16 we added American Floor Mats, and that one was closer: we were lower on 36 of 42 roll orders, and they were lower on 6.
Not every cart went our way. Some small orders, like single rolls in some thicknesses and small rubber tile orders, came in lower elsewhere, and those are what we're working on next. I co-founded FlooringInc, so I'm admittedly biased. Everything is dated below, so please feel free to check my work.
Same order, four receipts
Start with one real order: about 1,000 sq ft of black 3/8" rubber rolls, enough for a small studio or a big garage gym, shipped to a home in Chicago (ZIP 60614). For our side we used our Budget Rubber Rolls. They're designed to be our lowest-cost roll, and we believe they're comparable in quality to the rolls we priced at the other stores.
Our cart quoted $284.40 to ship 2,200 lb, for a delivered total of $2,151.90. Shipping the same footage cost $380.01 at Elite Floor Supply, $483.47 at Living.Fit and $575.68 at Greatmats.
It wasn't just Chicago
We ran the same order to 13 more cities on November 9, 2026. Our Budget Rubber Rolls came in lowest delivered in all 14, by $55.45 to $198.11 per order compared with the next-lowest store in each city.
Every city's numbers and each store's cart records
| City | ZIP | FlooringInc (Budget Rubber Rolls) | Elite Floor Supply | Living.Fit | Greatmats | We were lower by (order total) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Atlanta, GA | 30318 | $2.15 | $2.31 | $2.31 | $2.81 | $164.86 |
| Charlotte, NC | 28205 | $2.15 | $2.23 | $2.25 | $2.71 | $84.31 |
| Milwaukee, WI | 53202 | $2.15 | $2.22 | $2.49 | $2.72 | $71.83 |
| Tempe, AZ | 85281 | $2.15 | $2.25 | $2.58 | $3.03 | $96.44 |
| Chicago, IL | 60614 | $2.15 | $2.35 | $2.47 | $2.77 | $198.11 |
| Nashville, TN | 37211 | $2.18 | $2.38 | $2.33 | $2.72 | $155.93 |
| Philadelphia, PA | 19103 | $2.20 | $2.47 | $2.39 | $2.65 | $193.65 |
| Kansas City, MO | 64108 | $2.29 | $2.41 | $2.49 | $2.83 | $124.07 |
| Los Angeles, CA | 90012 | $2.30 | $2.40 | $2.60 | $3.10 | $101.13 |
| Dallas, TX | 75204 | $2.31 | $2.49 | $2.52 | $2.87 | $180.56 |
| Boston, MA | 02210 | $2.32 | $2.59 | $2.50 | $2.72 | $178.61 |
| Miami, FL | 33130 | $2.38 | $2.44 | $2.56 | $2.91 | $55.45 |
| Denver, CO | 80205 | $2.40 | $2.48 | $2.66 | $3.03 | $80.26 |
| Seattle, WA | 98103 | $2.53 | $2.69 | $2.75 | $3.11 | $165.01 |
Gym-size and business orders: 392 quotes, lowest in all 14 cities (Nov. 9-11, 2026)
If you're outfitting a garage gym, a studio, a school weight room or a commercial gym, you're probably buying 500 sq ft or more. Across 392 quotes in our November 9-11, 2026 test, our delivered price was the lowest in all 14 cities on all four orders: 500 and 1,000 sq ft of 3/8" rubber rolls and about 200 and 600 sq ft of padded gym turf, against every store that sells them (Elite Floor Supply doesn't sell turf).
To keep it fair, we also got business-address quotes from the other stores, and loading-dock quotes from Greatmats. 140 of their quotes were business or loading-dock prices, and we held every one up against our home-delivery price. None came in lower. To be clear about scope: we were lowest delivered on these gym-size orders as of those dates, not on every commercial order out there. Planning something bigger? Call our team at (866) 416-6388.
One roll, one flat rate
Small orders work differently. Our 1/4" Pre-Cut Tough Rubber Roll in 4x10 ships at a flat parcel rate, and in our November 10, 2026 check it was $39.99 in all 14 cities, Boston and Los Angeles alike. That made it the lowest delivered price in every city we tested that day.
The full scoreboard
We compare delivered price because that's what you pay. A cheap roll with expensive freight can cost more than a pricier roll that ships free.
| Order | FlooringInc (delivered) | Elite Floor Supply | Living.Fit | Greatmats |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| One 1/4" 4x10 rubber roll (40 sq ft) | $98.78 everywhere ($39.99 shipping) | $102.96 to $122.45 | $110.19 to $138.14 | $123.23 to $156.64 |
| 500 sq ft of 3/8" Budget Rubber Rolls | $2.37 to $2.78 per sq ft | $2.47 to $3.11 | $2.44 to $3.01 | $3.05 to $3.56 |
| 1,000 sq ft of 3/8" Budget Rubber Rolls | $2.15 to $2.53 per sq ft | $2.22 to $2.69 | $2.25 to $2.75 | $2.65 to $3.11 |
| Padded gym turf, about 200 sq ft | $5.78 to $7.55 per sq ft | Not sold | $8.82 to $13.37 | $10.51 to $11.36 |
| Padded gym turf, about 600 sq ft | $4.60 to $6.54 per sq ft | Not sold | $7.54 to $9.32 | $9.24 to $9.59 |
Ranges run from the cheapest city to the most expensive, so they can overlap. City by city, ours was lower every time in our November 9-11, 2026 test.
The fine print: our shipping charge on its own wasn't always the lowest. It was in 10 of 14 cities on the 1/4" roll and 8 of 14 on 1,000 sq ft, but only 4 of 14 on 500 sq ft. On turf it beat Living.Fit's in all 14 cities on both orders, and Greatmats' in 11 of 14 at about 200 sq ft but 1 of 14 at about 600 sq ft. On bigger orders, part of our edge is the price of the flooring itself, so compare the bottom line: product plus shipping.
On turf, our Performance Gym Turf with shock pad is about 5/8" thick on a foam pad. Living.Fit's has a 3/4" pile on a 5 mm foam pad. Greatmats' padded gym turfs were call-to-order, so we priced its RageTurf Motivate 17 mm, which has a 5 mm rubber backing. Our turf quotes are from November 11; theirs are from November 9.
Key Point: Compare delivered totals, not product prices. Put the same ZIP in each store's cart and look at the number you'll pay.
American Floor Mats, checked November 16, 2026
American Floor Mats doesn't show a shipping price on rubber rolls until checkout, so it wasn't part of our November 9-11 test. On November 16, 2026, we went through its checkout to the shipping step (no order placed) for the same three roll orders in the same 14 cities. We used its lowest-priced black roll in each thickness, its Vulcanized Rubber Flooring Rolls, against our own prices and shipping, checked the same day.
Our delivered price was lower on 36 of those 42 orders. American Floor Mats was lower on 6, by $0.83 to $16.03 per order: the single 1/4" roll in Philadelphia, 500 sq ft in Chicago, Charlotte and Philadelphia, and 1,000 sq ft in Philadelphia and Boston. Where we were lower, we led by up to $391.71 an order.
| Order | FlooringInc (delivered) | American Floor Mats | Cities where ours was lower |
|---|---|---|---|
| One 1/4" 4x10 rubber roll (40 sq ft) | $102.48 everywhere ($39.99 shipping) | $101.65 to $144.59 | 13 of 14 |
| 500 sq ft of 3/8" rubber rolls | $2.33 to $2.74 per sq ft | $2.36 to $2.82 | 11 of 14 |
| 1,000 sq ft of 3/8" rubber rolls | $2.11 to $2.48 per sq ft | $2.15 to $2.56 | 12 of 14 |
Their 1/4" roll costs less than ours, and our $39.99 flat shipping made up the difference in 13 of 14 cities. On the 3/8" orders the rolls cost about the same, so freight decided it. Their checkout needs a street address while our numbers are a home-delivery estimate for the ZIP, and their freight quote moved about 3% within an hour, so treat this as a snapshot.
We're not done with those six orders. Right now we're working to open an account with another national freight carrier to see whether it can lower our rates on some routes.
How we keep your shipping bill down
A freight bill comes down to four things, and we work on each one.
We shop the freight for you
We work with several national freight carriers and partners. Every freight order gets priced across them, and your shipping price is based on the lowest quote that comes back. New carriers don't get a free pass: before one can price your order, it has to show us it would save customers money.
Our size is a big part of why we can do this. FlooringInc has published more than 125,000 verified customer reviews across our sites and marketplaces, more than any of the other three stores in our November 9-11 test (as of November 2026, Living.Fit shows about 33,000, Greatmats about 10,000 on Trustpilot and Elite Floor Supply about 1,000). That volume gives us negotiating power with freight carriers that smaller shops don't have, and we pass it on as lower freight.
Update, November 16, 2026: Since our test, we've cut freight on our standard lines (pre-cut rubber rolls, rubber tiles and padded turf) by about 13 to 14% at every one of the 14 ZIPs we tested, and our typical minimum freight charge dropped from $343.69 to $295.97. Take 55 of our 8mm Strong Rubber Tiles shipped to Chicago: freight was $343.69 on November 9 and $295.97 on November 16, so that order costs $47.72 less delivered ($781.62 instead of $829.34). Prices move in both directions, so your cart always has the final word.
When the freight truck shows up
Larger orders ship LTL freight (less than truckload, meaning your pallet shares a truck with other shipments), with liftgate service included in most areas and curbside drop-off, usually in 5 to 7 business days. The driver won't bring it inside, so line up some help. Our shipping and delivery page has the details.
- Schedule it. Call the carrier on your tracking notice to book a delivery window.
- Be there if you can. Some deliveries need a signature, and some carriers will leave the pallet without one. Being there lets you check it before the driver leaves.
- Inspect, then write it down. Count the rolls or boxes and look for damage. If you sign, note any damage or shortage on the delivery receipt first, because a claim depends on that note.
- Take photos, then call us at (866) 416-6388, right away if the pallet was left without a signature.
How we checked
- When and where: November 9, 2026 (rolls and competitor turf), November 10 (the 1/4" roll) and November 11 (our padded turf), at residential ZIPs in the 14 cities above. American Floor Mats on November 16, 2026.
- How: each store's own cart shipping estimator, with a ZIP and nothing else personal. American Floor Mats shows shipping only at checkout, so there we used a street address in each city and stopped at the shipping step. No orders, prices before tax.
- Matching: black rubber at the same thickness, compared per sq ft where sizes differ. Where a store sold two close matches, we used its cheaper one.
- Our rolls: Budget Rubber Rolls for the 500 and 1,000 sq ft orders, our lowest-cost 3/8" roll (custom cut, 15 ft minimum length), which we believe is comparable in quality to the rolls we priced elsewhere. It ships a few days later than our pre-cut rolls, and our other 3/8" rolls cost more and weren't the lowest in most cities.
Flooring shipping FAQ
Does FlooringInc offer free shipping on rubber flooring?
On some products. FlooringInc's 1/4" Tough Rubber Mats, Nitro garage tiles and 5/8" foam tiles ship free, and you can see all of our rubber flooring that ships free. Rubber rolls carry a flat parcel rate, such as $39.99 for a 1/4" 4x10 Pre-Cut Tough Rubber Roll, and freight orders get a live quote in the cart once you enter your ZIP.
Why do some rubber rolls ship by freight?
Rubber is dense, and parcel carriers limit how heavy one package can be. A 1,000 sq ft order of 3/8" rubber rolls weighs about 2,200 lb, so it travels on a pallet by LTL (less than truckload) freight.
Is a business address cheaper for freight?
It can be. Carriers charge more to deliver to a home. FlooringInc's cart estimate shows the home price, and checkout checks your address automatically, so a business is only charged for the delivery service it needs and can skip the liftgate if it has a loading dock or forklift.
What is liftgate delivery, and is it free?
A powered platform on the truck lowers your pallet to the ground, so you don't need a loading dock or forklift. On FlooringInc freight orders, liftgate service is included in the quote in most areas.
How much does LTL freight shipping cost for flooring?
It depends on weight and distance. In FlooringInc's November 9, 2026 test, LTL freight on 500 to 1,000 sq ft of 3/8" Budget Rubber Rolls to a home ZIP ran $250.51 to $657.60 across 14 cities. A single 1/4" 4x10 rubber roll ships by parcel for a flat $39.99.
Is FlooringInc cheaper for big gym orders?
On the gym-size orders in our November 9-11, 2026 test, it was. Across 392 quotes, FlooringInc had the lowest delivered price (product plus shipping) in all 14 cities on 500 and 1,000 sq ft of 3/8" rubber rolls and on about 200 and 600 sq ft of padded gym turf, against Living.Fit, Elite Floor Supply (rolls only) and Greatmats. None of the 140 competitor business-address or loading-dock quotes beat our home-delivery price.
Which online store has the lowest delivered price on rubber flooring?
In our November 9-11, 2026 test of four online stores, FlooringInc had the lowest delivered price (product plus shipping) in all 14 cities on a 1/4" 4x10 rubber roll, on 500 and 1,000 sq ft of 3/8" rubber rolls and on padded gym turf. In a November 16, 2026 check of American Floor Mats, ours was lower on 36 of 42 roll orders and theirs on 6. Shipping by itself wasn't always the lowest, and some small orders came in lower elsewhere.
This isn't the end of it
These quotes are a snapshot of one week in November, not a finish line. We're going to keep driving down what you pay, for shipping and for the flooring itself, starting with the orders that didn't go our way. That November 16 freight cut is the kind of work I mean, and it won't be the last.
We shop our competition every week. Some weeks someone beats us on a price, and we go to work on it. My aim is for FlooringInc to be the place you trust to find the best deal right out of the gate.
Find the same or a comparable item for less at another online store? Tell us, and once our team verifies it, we'll beat it (terms apply).
Ready to shop? Enter your ZIP in the cart and you'll see shipping (free on many products) before you check out. Start with our rubber rolls, or order free samples first so you know the color before a pallet ships. We also carry rubber tiles, garage flooring, foam flooring and gym turf. Planning a big order? Call our team at (866) 416-6388. And if you check my numbers and find something different, I want to hear about it.
Thank you from the whole team and me.
Rubber FlooringBuying Guideshippingfreight deliveryliftgate deliveryrubber rollsprice comparison





